“Ke ami?” – A must-read book review of a must-read book
by neo
“A once-in-a-lifetime debut by this author.” – Debut magazine
“Four out of Five bindis.” – South Asian Identity Exploring Website
“I’d be on the edge of my seat if I wasn’t lying on the beach!” - Amazon.com reviewer.
“A tour de farce!” – Neo
“Ke ami” is a path-breaking novel by debutante novelist Kavya Mehta. The books deals with the journey of a young woman, Mala, as she explores, rejects, discovers, redefines and then finally questions the very core of her Indian cultural identity; an issue that has not been explored by contemporary Indian writers since last Wednesday.
Mala Chattopadhyay hails from a traditional Bengali/Hindu Indian family that will be familiar and instantly identifiable; at least to European and North American readers. For Indian readers who might be more fuzzy about what goes on in traditional families living in small Bengali towns, Ms. Mehta describes the Chattopadhyay family in painstakingly vivid detail. Mala’s family consists of a Father who is a daktar (literally: “doctor”), a Mother who works in a skul (literally: “school”) and a quirky Brother who is notable for being the only character in this book that is devoid of an identity crisis.
In what is perhaps the most poignant scene in the novel, a warm breeze flaps open a window that is draped by a curtain adorned with an intricate pattern, oddly reminiscent of the living room couch in the Chattopadhyay residence. The window knocks a bowl of vermillion onto Mala’s head. But, instead of causing intense irritation to Mala’s eyes, the vermillion attaches itself to her forehead. Mala’s mother takes it as a sign; it is time to close the window.
Alas, the vermillion incident also portends a somewhat less orange turn of events for Mala. As if being raised in a typical Indian family were not hard enough on her emotions, things are about to get positively bittersweet; Mala gets married (the marriage is arranged, but with Mala’s demure, if endearingly hesitant consent) to a Bengali Indian American boy, Harish, who has just graduated from MIT*.
Soon after her arrival in America, Mala’s life takes an interesting twist, the first of several increasingly interesting twists: she meets Gbjkel, an exotic young woman of Syrian-Kurdish-Molvanian descent. In a poignantly allegoric scene, both Mala and Gbjkel are searching for an affordable source of lighting for their new homes and end up reaching for the same halogen lamp for $10.95 at Walmart. Introductions occur between the two women, and Mala and Gbjkel embark on a life-changing friendship that is the subject of much of the novel. However, many readers will be left wondering if this friendship could have acquired vastly more personal hues, had the two women not been content with merely comparing cultural notes over coffee.
The central theme in this book is the conflict in Mala’s life. On the one hand, she is struggling with her assimilation into American society: a task made even more challenging given that she had barely understood the True Meaning of the Bengali life she left behind in India. On the other hand, a harshly materialistic Harish wants Mala to get a job and help with a mortgage that is looking increasingly foolish by the month, rather than spending long hours reading Indian (and Syrian-Kurdish-Molvanian) literature.
Bottom line: If you’re an Indian who’s ever wondered, “Who am I?”, but have had little or no time to truly explore your identity, this book is for you. You will identify with Mala, who asks a similar question in her own, hauntingly Bengali way: “ke ami?“ (literally: “Who am I?”)
* * * *
(* An earlier version of this review erroneously suggested that Harish had graduated from Yale (instead of MIT); the error completely changed the tone of the review, and is deeply regretted. -ed)





Looking forward to the book….Can you provide some spoilers, please?
Are you sure Harish is not a a Ph.d?
Do their children (one boy and one girl) first excel at academics, then rebel and spend the rest of their lives finding themselves?
Do all Indians visit India only once in ten years or so?
Great post… as always!
Like or Dislike:
1
1
Revati,
I’ll give you a huge spoiler: Mala never finds out the answer, and leaves the door wide open for interpretation and hour-long speeches by the author. :)
-N
Like or Dislike:
3
1
Great review- hits exactly all the points one would want to know about!
Oh and like Revati, I have a question about spoilers. Is there a scene in which Mala goes into the loo and there follows a two-page description of this toilet, the one back home and any others that she’s ever been in? Also included in the description would be details of colour, consistency, texture, etc. of the output. Every Indian author/character seems to neccessitate a bowel movement description, and of course a page that makes it look like Indians walk around in their own filth all the time. Last one I read was Kiran Desai – some “prestigious” award or the other winner, which is why I read it(my fault entirely) – which had the sentence “flecks landing on the floor…” or something to that effect… Is this one of the qualifiers for International awards?
Like or Dislike:
1
1
D,
International awards are handed out based on very precise, scientific and transparent guidelines that are not shared with us.
-N
Like or Dislike:
2
1
Hi Neo,
@Bottom line: may be u had asked same ? 2 ur self…..
n found ur ans. or finding ur ans. u cm to india!!!
and on Indian cultural identity we(99% of indians) have proud on our fake asscent…….
Like or Dislike:
0
2
Can we have a sequel please? The one where Mala’s daughter falls for a white boy. Thanks.
Like or Dislike:
1
1
i_r_squared,
True story: I pitched this story idea to a (female) friend. She said that the story was touching and would be nice to read. The rest is history.
-Neo
PS: It’s a good thing she’s not reading my blog. :P
Like or Dislike:
1
1
If I didn’t laugh so much, I’d have cried at the thought of the course taken by Indian ‘literature’ (really?).
You should take up the idea of a sequel seriously. The one where the only son (why is it always a young man?) who goes to an IIM and the life he leads there! Oh, the turmoil!
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Two choices for the cover:
1. Exotic spices and rich red lips
2. Saree/duppatta, anklets and gold jewelry
Like or Dislike:
1
1
Soli,
I’ve read several wikipedia paragraphs on photography, and I can tell you – the most important feature of the book cover will be the expression on the woman’s face. It needs to be …. poignant.
-Neo
Like or Dislike:
3
2
What? It is not necessary to be an IIT-IIM alumnus in order to qualify to be an Indian author?
What? Coveting (and cavorting with) the dean’s daughter is not a pre-requisite to be an award-winning Indian novelist?
What? There are no poignant or touching scenes involving the 3 Fs – filth, food and (extended) family?
Man, why didn’t you say so earlier? I would have staked my claim to being the the author of the PJ times No.1 best-selling (how many No.1 best-sellers *do* they have anyways?) book in the Indian-hypothetical-semi-poignant-partially-reminiscent-completely-redundant-over-hyped-glimpses-of-the-authors-own-life genre.
And oh! Thanks for the excellent book review. Loved the “Bottom Line” part the most :)
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Kiran,
I’ve seen interviews where the author says “Well I researched this book by making nearly three trips to India”. I swear it’s true. Don’t make me take names, but it’s one of those best-selling authors you allude to.
-N
Like or Dislike:
1
1
Ha! Well, I wonder whether those 3 visits were the 3 mistakes of the author’s life .. ..
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Will make sure I read it, I have always wondered, ‘Ke ami?’
Like or Dislike:
0
1
And ? Did you find the answer? :)
-N
Like or Dislike:
0
1
[...] Neo Indian, always hilarious, reviews a new must-read [...]
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Indian chic lit is like Mills and Boon. Very very predictable. Sad that we can’t have any sci-fi writers. Even the Twilight series kind will suffice for now.
Don’t forget khol/kajal filled eyes and a big bindi for the poignant look on the cover.
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Do you like Samit Basu ? Look him up!
-N
Like or Dislike:
1
1
So many books have taught us how to explore this “who am i” quandary. It would be interesting to read a young writers perspective.
somebody wrote on cultural identity in the comments section. Its true, we find more peace in moving away from the “indianess”. accent , glitter are words to support it.
Good read write more.
Like or Dislike:
0
1
vinay,
Why do you think there’s more peace in moving away from indianness?
-N
PS: I liked your “Lazy God” post.
Like or Dislike:
0
2
:)Thanks neo.
About the comment, i mean this is what i have observed in us. I can see people around me who think picking up that ‘american accent’ or a dsr snap besides Brooklyn bridge is so cool. I mean in one way we boast of our roots without respecting them really, Hypocracy kills an institution. Only if they stop staring at Tower of pizzas, they can see their own/India’s worth. I mean ask yourself what is the sole thing that is binding us Indians?
I may sound cynical and off topic, down with over work. :)
Like or Dislike:
1
1
So have you negotiated a deal with Mira Nair for the movie yet? You might want to rush, Kal Penn will be busy with Harold and Kumar 3 soon!
Like or Dislike:
0
1
I feel Mira Nair will not do justice to this movie. Her style is not melodramatic enough for me.
Like or Dislike:
0
1
The first blogpost I read dealt with the same question (a few summers ago). Read many more in the years following.
I doubt if there would be an answer to the whole question in the book. The plot would more of a setting for the author to go into a monologue of thoughts on this matter through conversations and meanderings of the protagonists thoughts, and certain actions which are to carry more significance than what meets the eye.
But with no answer will it really be worth that much of a read? Just wondering…
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Sumit – I share your concerns.
Like or Dislike:
0
1